XH3002 Clinical Judgment Through Assessment: Decision Making – Sample Assessment
XH3002 Assessment Instructions Summary
The XH3002 Performance Task assesses clinical judgment through two Mursion-based scenarios set at Neighborhood Clinic. Learners gather information from avatars and use that information to make reasoned nursing decisions. The first scenario centers on Atsumi Yoshida, a clinic nurse who discusses a returning patient, Teo Kimura. The learner summarizes what Atsumi reports about Mr. Kimura’s previous appointment, evaluates how she applied clinical judgment, and identifies what should receive additional attention during the learner’s own assessment. The response should include questions that would clarify Mr. Kimura’s physical symptoms and other health influences, while also explaining how the four clinical-judgment processes— noticing, interpreting, responding, and reflecting—would guide assessment and decision making. The learner must also consider whether cultural competence or implicit bias could affect interpretation of the case.
The second scenario involves Serena Miranda, a young first-time mother, and her one-month-old son, Jorge. The learner summarizes the information obtained from Serena, identifies concerns about the infant’s condition, and considers failure to thrive as a possible concern. The assessment asks what additional questions should be asked, what should be observed during Jorge’s examination, and what next steps would be appropriate using components of the nursing process. The learner again applies noticing, interpreting, responding, and reflecting to explain clinical reasoning. The work should be based on the simulations, course learning resources, and any additional appropriate sources, with evidence cited for statements made. The completed template should be approximately three to four pages plus a reference page, follow scholarly-writing conventions, and use APA citations and references where appropriate.
Completed XH3002 Assessment
Health Assessment
XH3002: Clinical Judgment Through Assessment
Competency
Assessment:
Decision Making for Clinical Judgment
Student Name: Date:
Part 1 – Nurse Scenario: Atsumi Yoshida and Returning Patient Mr. Teo Kimura
Summarize the information you learned from nurse Atsumi Yoshida about Teo Kimura and his previous appointment at Neighborhood Clinic.
Nurse Atsumi Yoshida helped me understand that Mr. Teo has joint pain issues, which he showed during his last visit and current visit. Mr. Kimura did not follow the recommended treatment, and this led to his worsened condition on his return visit. The nurse Atsumi Yoshida shared her fear about his failure to follow treatment instructions and its negative impact on his symptoms. Our main point is that doctors need to teach patients well and should stay in touch with them afterward (Sapeni & Said, 2020).
Evaluate the nurse’s application of clinical judgment based on what she stated and explain your reasoning.
To evaluate patient care Atsumi applied specific assessment procedures in patient care.
Noticing: Atsumi recognized that Mr. Kimura had persistent joint pain, which needed medical attention.
Interpreting: She recognized that his pain was only part of his chronic condition because he failed to follow his prescribed treatment. The patient's emotional and mental aspects of following treatment should have been included in the analysis.
Responding: She implemented good clinical practice by suggesting a next appointment since his health needs required further examination.
Reflecting: Though Atsumi studied his lack of treatment in the past, she did not extensively investigate what led to his choices, such as adverse medication effects, trouble understanding the plan, and social difficulties. Clinical judgment needs complete insight into how social factors alongside psychological and cultural features impact a person's health status. I support what Atsumi did but would research the specific reasons for Mr. Kimura's treatment avoidance during the follow-up appointment (Benner, 2021).
In your appointment with Teo Kimura, explain what you would look for and pay particular attention to based on the information you received from Atsumi Yoshida and your assessment of her clinical judgment.
At our next session I would investigate what caused Mr. Kimura to ignore the recommended treatment. Finding out what prevents Mr. Kimura from taking his medication effectively requires examining both possible side effects and his understanding of treatment alongside his emotional problems. Awareness of these problems enables better modification of the chosen treatment strategy. Effective treatment of chronic diseases relies on teaching patients while fixing roadblocks to their treatment follow-up. Factors that influence health status are necessary to achieve better care results (Sapeni et al., 2020).
What questions would you ask Mr. Kimura to understand his physical symptoms?
I will ask Mr. Kimura several questions to get details about his pain levels from last week.
How intense was your joint pain last week?
How does your body feel after a night's sleep?
How does the joint pain impact your everyday actions and basic movements?
These questions help us identify how bad his symptoms are to define proper treatment options (Cooke et al., 2023).
What questions would you ask Mr. Kimura to understand other factors that may affect his health?
In addition to direct health inquiries, I would want to learn about his overall well-being by asking these questions.
Tell me about your experience taking your current medicine. Do you have problems using your current medicine?
What life changes or stress have you experienced that damage your health today?
What does Mr. Kimura think about the treatment the clinic wants to use?
These questions enable me to detect how outside stressors and lifestyle changes influence his health and medicine response (Sapeni & Said, 2020).
Explain aspects of clinical judgment—noticing, interpreting, responding, reflecting—that would support your assessment and decision making on Mr. Kimura’s health.
My patient assessment of Mr. Kimura includes these specific clinical judgment steps:
Noticing: The persistent joint pain in his body requires urgent medical attention, according to my evaluation.
Interpreting:Mr. Kimura's health problems may worsen because he ignores medications and other relevant factors that affect his situation.
Responding:Creating an improved treatment plan that mentors Mr. Kimura on better care compliance and studies medical alternatives to his side effects.
Reflecting:After the follow-up, he examined if Mr. Kimura took his medicine better and experienced fewer joint pain symptoms (Horne et al., 2020).
Are there questions about cultural competence and/or implicit bias in this scenario? Explain your thinking.
An understanding of cultural norms and unconscious bias needs to guide the nurse through this case. Mr. His cultural upbringing may affect his beliefs about healthcare treatment. His biases could cause problems when he does not follow medical recommendations. Understand his cultural beliefs about health care for better individual service. The recognition of diverse cultural factors between patients and healthcare providers can improve their exchanges and treatment success rates (Campinha-Bacote, 2020).
Part 2 – Patient Scenario: Serena Miranda and Her 1-month-old Son, Jorge
Summarize the information you learned from Serena Miranda that would inform your examination of Jorge and application of clinical judgment.
One-month-old Jorge cannot eat properly and struggles to put on weight, according to his mother, Serena Miranda. She reported that Jorge eats small amounts at irregular times and cannot properly match his mouth to the breast. These problems put him at risk for undernutrition. At this important time for a boy's brain development, good eating and weight gain must take place (Cooke et al., 2023).
Based on this information, what concerns would you have about Jorge’s condition?
With the information that Serena gave, I would be worried that Jorge is failing to thrive, which is when there is not enough weight gain or poor feeding (Sapeni et al., 2020). Latching problems could be a feeding issue, either due to poor milk supply, latch issues, or a medical condition. He may also be fussing due to some gastrointestinal intolerance or lack of nutrition that needs to be addressed immediately.
If your concern were failure to thrive, what questions would you ask to understand more?
To boost my understanding of Jorge's medical state, I would want to speak with his main caretaker, Serena.
Tell me how often Jorge consumes food and how long each feeding session lasts.
Does he seem distressed during feedings?
Would you choose breastfeeding only or complement breast milk with formula?
The feed questions find what stops his nutrition from going inside properly and whether he hurts when feeding, which slows down his weight increase (Cooke et al., 2023).
When you examine Jorge, explain what you would look for and pay particular attention to in your examination based on the information you gathered.
In my examination I would pay special attention to analyzing Jorge's weight and feeding methods.
I will compare Jorge's measurements to health standards to check if he is growing correctly.
I should watch how well Jorge takes the breast during breastfeeding.
Identify any nursing signs of dehydration and poor nutrition, including dry skin and lack of skin flexibility. Measuring and watching Jorge allows healthcare experts to detect failure-to-thrive problems so they can develop correct treatment plans (Cooke et al., 2023).
Explain your next steps for Jorge and Serena Miranda based on components of the nursing process and your reasoning.
The patient should see an experienced pediatric doctor to examine his medical situation when regular diet changes do not help improve his development (Sapeni et al., 2020). Until the next week, I will teach Serena how to breastfeed properly while tracking Jorge's feeding habits and weight development. Parents and medical teams must start early help and training to create better results when infants have feeding problems.
Explain aspects of clinical judgment—noticing, interpreting, responding, reflecting—that would support your decision making.
When dealing with Jorge, I would take these steps for clinical judgment:
Noticing: I closely watch for feeding symptoms that suggest poor nutrition development.
Interpreting: Signs that patients need help suggest the need for better feeding support.
Responding: My response includes educating Serena about breastfeeding and advising her to seek specialized care.
Reflecting: Through reflection I check if Jorge responds well to our interventions and make necessary changes to his care plan (Benner, 2021).
References
Benner, P. (2021). From novice to expert: Excellence and power in clinical nursing practice. Pearson. http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/00000446-198412000-00025
Campinha-Bacote, J. (2020). The process of cultural competence in the delivery of healthcare services: A model of care. Journal of Transcultural Nursing, 31(2), 107-113. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2021.103171
Cooke, R., Goulet, O., Huysentruyt, K., Joosten, K., Khadilkar, A. V., Mao, M., ... & Singhal, A.(2023). Catch‐Up Growth in Infants and Young Children With Faltering Growth: ExpertOpinion to Guide General Clinicians. Journal of pediatric gastroenterology and nutrition, 77(1), 7-15. https://doi.org/10.1097/MPG.0000000000003784
Horne, R., Chapman, S., Parham, R., Freemantle, N., Forbes, A., & Cooper, V. (2020). Understanding patients' adherence to treatment: Theoretical models and practical applications. Psychology and Health, 35(4), 375-392. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3846635/
Mousavinasab, E. S., Kalhori, S. R. N., Zarifsanaiey, N., Rakhshan, M., & Ghazisaeedi, M. (2020). Nursing process education: A review of methods and characteristics. Nurse Education in Practice, 48, 102886. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2020.102886
Sapeni, M. A. A. R., & Said, S. (2020). The effectiveness of case-based learning in increasing critical thinking of nursing students: A literature review. Enfermería Clínica, 30, 182-185. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enfcli.2019.07.073
Need help with this Tempo course?
Get in touch for tutoring and study support.